We updated this article in June 2022 to add more information about each featured product, based on extensive testing done by the Good Housekeeping Institute. Several of our original top-rated picks, selected by the Beauty Lab, remain the same, but we removed several out-of-stock products and added three new picks, including ones from Pacifica, Dieux and Good Molecules.
For those morning-afters when you haven’t slept a wink (think: red-eye flights, bachelorette parties, the eve of a big meeting), undereye masks are calling your name. Unlike a sheet mask or a traditional skincare face mask, these patches are formulated specifically for your delicate under eyes to target eye-specific issues like fine lines and crow’s feet. Uniquely curved and formulated to stay put, they’re perfect to slap on your clean, dry under eyes anytime you’re feeling puffy or swollen, morning or night.
At the Good Housekeeping Institute Beauty Lab, we test thousands of skincare products year-round to help our readers rest easy knowing they’re investing in products that actually work. Most undereye patches claim to do anything from hydrating and firming the skin underneath the eyes, to reducing fine lines, diminishing puffiness and dark circles or brightening the eye area — but only some actually do the trick. That said, we parsed through 43 of the most popular undereye masks on the market and tested on 228 consumers to narrow down the field and recommend the best picks that actually work.
Our top picks:
Below are the best undereye patches you can buy, a combination of our top-tested products, editors’ and expert picks, and cult favorites that have stood the test of time. Don’t forget to follow up with a best-tested eye cream and a concealer for your most awake-looking eyes ever.
1
BEST OVERALL UNDER EYE PATCHES
Hydro Cool Firming Eye Gels (8 count)
- Visibly reduced fine lines
- Made testers’ undereyes feel hydrated
For on-the-go rejuvenation, these eye patches — designed to work in just 10 minutes — ranked easiest to use in our tests. Testers gave them perfect marks for having a pleasant fragrance and staying put without leaving any unpleasant residue behind. In the Lab, they received high marks for diminishing fine lines and wrinkles — by 23% in our tests.
Testers also gave this set one of the highest scores for hydration, with one saying, “loved the way my under eye skin felt after using this product,” and that skin “looked noticeably different.” The asymmetric shape and generous size tackle a myriad of issues and can extend to reach crow’s feet, too.
2
BEST VALUE UNDER EYE PATCHES
FlashPatch Eye Gels (30 Pairs)
- Proven soothing and hydrating benefits
- Helps reduce the appearance of fine lines
Clocking in at about $1.67 per use, these undereye gel masks are an economical choice that delivers serious results. The gels feel instantly soothing as the patches go on, and testers liked that they stayed put during application and left a serum-like residue behind that consumers felt hydrated skin. Lab tests showed this mask improved the look of fine lines and wrinkles by 9% immediately after application and a quick five-minute usage time means you’ll see results fast.
3
MOST POPULAR UNDER EYE PATCHES ON AMAZON
24K Gold Eye Mask (20 Pairs)
- Made with skin-plumping ingredients
- Individual packets great for travel
Though we haven’t tested these in the Lab, Amazon reviewers cannot get enough of these luxe-looking eye patches. With well over 15,000 5-star ratings, these gold patches are the top-seller in eye masks. Reviewers swear that applied twice weekly, “it keeps eyes looking young firm and healthy.” One even says the formula is “better than Botox.” The brand says the patches are formulated with hyaluronic acid and collagen and that you’ll see results in 30 minutes flat.
4
BEST UNDER EYE PATCHES FOR PUFFINESS
Hydrogel Eye Patches (30 pairs)
- GH Beauty Award Winner
- Visibly reduced the appearance of puffiness
- Extracts may not be ideal for sensitive skin
If bags and puffiness are your main issues, reach for this 2021 Beauty Award winner. The effective patches had 80% of testers agreeing that eye area puffiness was reduced after just one use, and 96% of testers said they felt instantly refreshing. They’re infused with a range of botanical extracts like pear, blueberry and blackberry and glycerin, which helps to soften and hydrate skin.
5
BEST REUSABLE UNDER EYE PATCHES
Forever Eye Mask
- More sustainable than other eye masks
- Silicone patches stay put
Tired of tossing out single-use patches? With an eye cream or a serum in hand, opt for these reusable Dieux eye masks, designed to increase the efficacy of your favorite eye cream or serum. “These are a godsend for those who struggle to keep over-soaked eye patches in place and have no time to wait for the excess product to absorb,” Senior Chemist Sabina Wizemann says. “The non-porous silicone patches are slender yet durable and quickly adhered to the skin, preventing evaporation and extending the product beyond the surface.” Its elegant aluminum case allows for easy breezy storage, with cleaning taking next to no time. Store them in the fridge for a cooling kick.
6
BEST UNDER EYE PATCHES FOR BAGS
Vegan Collagen Hydro-Treatment Undereye & Smile Lines
- Made with hydrating ingredients
- Can be used on eyelids
- Only offers one single-use pair
Lift and rejuvenate your eyes with these top-performing patches. Soaked in glycerin, vegan collagen, cucumber extract, hyaluronic acid and more, these leave under eyes plumped and smoothed with a dewy finish, according to our Lab experts. Apply them under the eyes for 10-15 minutes, but don’t toss them just yet: “After using them under my eyes, I soaked them more in the remaining serum in the pouch, flipped them and placed them on my upper eye area,” a Lab expert says, so feel free to use them on crepey eyelids as well!
7
BEST UNDER EYE PATCHES FOR WRINKLES
Benefiance WrinkleResist24 Pure Retinol Express Smoothing Eye Mask (12 Pairs)
- Great for mature skin
- Claims to reduce the appearance of fine lines
- Retinol may be irritating on sensitive skin
If you have crow’s feet and visible signs of aging around your eyes that you want to nix, these retinol-infused patches are for you. Though we haven’t Lab tested these patches, we stand by the fact that retinol is a the gold star of anti-aging skincare ingredients: It’s proven to speed up cellular turnover to boost skin’s collagen production to both minimize and prevent fine lines, meaning it works on existing lines and stops new ones from popping up. Reviewers swear they immediately improve the look of wrinkles and puffiness.
8
BEST UNDER EYE PATCHES FOR DARK CIRCLES
Caffeine Energizing Hydrogel Eye Patches
- Uses niacinamide to brighten dark circles
- Feels cooling on skin
Look like you’ve just downed a cup of joe with these caffeinated hydrogel patches. Their gel-like texture feels soothing on a.m. skin, while its 1% caffeine ingredient claims to wake up sleepy eyes. For those looking to target dark circles, its brightening niacinamide is a great dark spot-fighting addition to your skincare routine. While we haven’t Lab tested these, one GH editor loves how cooling these feel to prep for her makeup routine.
9
BEST MULTI-USE UNDER EYE PATCHES
Eye Therapy Patch (6 Pairs)
- Reusable
- Comes with a metal case for storage
- Some reviewers say it’s not ideal for dark circles
A celeb favorite, these eye patches are actually reusable for up to three wears, which means less waste and more bang for your buck — if you follow the instructions, each use comes out to around $2.72 (though some reviewers say, “I use them more than 3 times each and still totally works”). They’re made with wheat germ oil, ceramides, and avocado oil, and reviewers “love the way it hydrates and reduces puffiness.” After wearing the patches for 30 minutes, simply replace them with the included chic metal case until you’re ready for your next round.
10
BEST UNDER EYE PATCHES FOR DRY SKIN
Water Drench Hyaluronic Cloud Hydra-Gel Eye Patches (30 Pairs)
- Great for dry, sensitive skin
- Larger-than-average size
- Must keep sealed to prevent drying out
Think of these as a drink of water and a cup of coffee for your under eyes. The Water Drench line is packed with hyaluronic acid that works to bring hydration to skin all day long, while caffeine brightens eyes. These patches are also formulated with skin-soothing ceramides and collagen to soften skin and smooth lines. We haven’t Lab-tested these, but one of our beauty editors swears by them to quickly hydrate and brighten even dry, sensitive skin.
11
BEST UNDER EYE PATCHES FOR TRAVEL
Baggage Claim Eye Masks (6 Pairs)
- Stay-put adhesion
- Made with hydrating and soothing ingredients
- May not be as saturated with serum as other masks
While we haven’t tested these Instagram-famous patches, we do know you’ll feel like a star using these glitzy masks while traveling. They are formulated with elastic for a snug, custom fit and are formulated with hyaluronic acid to hydrate and fill the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles, while aloe and lavender soothe skin. Since they’re made of cellulose fiber and gold foil, not slippery gel, they’ll stay put even if you’re running to catch a flight.
12
BEST PRINTED EYE PATCHES
Eye Got This (5 Pairs)
- Helps diminish the appearance of fine lines
- Hugs eye contours to lock in moisture
- May not be as effective for dark circles
These holographic eye patches are as cute as they are effective (even Chrissy Teigen loves ’em!). Amazon reviewers say these masks feel great and brighten undereye skin after use, but don’t do much in the way of dark circles. “I felt that the tiny lines by the corners of my eyes were much less noticeable,” says one reviewer. “My whole eye area felt hydrated.”
13
BEST PLUMPING UNDEREYE MASKS
Bright Eye Firming Mask (5 Pack)
- Made with hydrating hyaluronic acid
- Esthetician-backed brand
Celebrity esthetician Joanna Vargas is known for her facials that leave skin looking instantly refreshed and glowing. When you can’t head in for a salon service, these eye masks are the next best thing. We haven’t tested these, but love that they’re made with silk protein, hyaluronic acid and algae extract to hydrate and plump eye skin for immediate smooth-looking results.
14
BEST SOOTHING UNDER EYE PATCHES
Clean Eye Mask (1 pair)
- Budget-friendly
- Great smelling
Sephora reviewers love the soothing and depuffing feeling of this cucumber set. Instead of being made of a gel-like material, our pros love that these are made of a natural fiber so they feel more reminiscent of sheet masks made specially for your eyes. Sephora has many different iterations of eye masks, but cucumber is the reviewer favorite to reduce puffiness. It’s just as relaxing as placing fresh-sliced cucumbers on your eyes — but a lot more functional.
How we test best under eye patches
Our Good Housekeeping Institute Beauty Lab chemists send products (with labels obscured) to testers with undereye concerns like fine lines and wrinkles, dark circles, puffiness and lack of firmness. After using the masks at least three times, the women answer a detailed survey on performance, ease of use and efficacy. We also take in-Lab measurements before and after use with the Visia Complexion Analyzer, which can measure wrinkles, spots, UV spots, pore size and skin texture.
The top performers in our last study scored points for not leaving an unpleasant residue and not interfering with any makeup application following use, making them ideal for applying first thing in the morning, before a night out, or on the go. Bonus: 79% of testers reported softening, cooling, and relaxing benefits across the board, so try ’em during your next self-care regimen.
Do undereye patches actually work?
Yes — The most common benefit seen with these products in the Lab was softening and smoothing of fine lines and wrinkles immediately following application. About 90% of the panelists agreed that the patches hydrated their skin.
As far as eliminating dark circles and undereye bags, our findings only saw occasional tightening benefits, low reduction of undereye bags and little (if any) improvement of dark circles. That means that undereye patches really are best for acute issues like puffiness and tired eyes, and you’ll probably see the most results immediately after application.
Why trust Good Housekeeping?
The Good Housekeeping Institute features a team of product experts and scientists who frequently collaborate in making the best recommendations out there. Executive Director of the Health, Beauty & Sustainability Lab Birnur Aral and Deputy Editor Jessica Teich teamed up in naming the best undereye patches listed above: Birnur ran the Lab and consumer tests, analyzed the data and compiled them in a technical report, while Jessica distilled the findings, gathered additional recommendations and wrote this roundup.
In addition to her 15 years of leading clinical and consumer testing in the Beauty Lab, Birnur has R&D experience through her seven-year stint at Unilever U.S. and contributes her expertise across beauty categories, from anti-aging products to sunscreen safety. Jessica has over 10 years of experience researching, testing and writing about skincare products, including skincare ingredients (like hyaluronic acid and ceramides), moisturizers and more.
Jessica Teich, Good Housekeeping Institute
Deputy Editor
Jessica is the deputy editor at the Good Housekeeping Institute and a longtime product tester, reviewer, writer, and editor of beauty, lifestyle, and home content.
Birnur Aral, Ph.D., Good Housekeeping Institute
Executive Director, Beauty, Health & Sustainability Lab
Birnur Aral is the executive director of the Beauty, Health & Sustainability Lab at the Good Housekeeping Institute, where she oversees all Lab tests and applications for the GH Seal, the Green GH Seal and the GH Innovation emblem.
This content is created and maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page to help users provide their email addresses. You may be able to find more information about this and similar content at piano.io